Eddie Murphy Handpicked Lisa Lisa To Play In "Coming To America" But Her Husband Rejected

Eddie Murphy’s iconic 1988 comedy Coming to America is remembered for its legendary cast, timeless humor, and unforgettable romance between Prince Akeem and Lisa McDowell. But what many fans don’t know is that the role of Lisa was originally intended for a different leading lady: Lisa Lisa, the chart-topping music sensation from Lisa Lisa and Cult Jam.

At the height of her fame in the late 1980s, Lisa Lisa—known for hits like “I Wonder If I Take You Home” and “Head to Toe”—was not only dominating the airwaves but also catching the attention of Hollywood. So much so that Eddie Murphy himself personally handpicked her to star opposite him as his love interest in what would become one of his most celebrated films.

Lisa Lisa had the charisma, the star power, and the beauty to take on the role of Lisa McDowell—a strong, independent New Yorker who captures the heart of an African prince. The casting would have paired two major pop culture figures of the era and could have taken her career in an entirely new direction.

But behind the scenes, a very personal factor led to her turning down the opportunity of a lifetime. According to sources, Lisa Lisa declined the role because her then-husband disapproved of her taking on such a high-profile part—particularly one involving romantic scenes.

Ultimately, the part of Lisa McDowell went to Shari Headley, whose performance became central to the film’s enduring charm. Headley’s portrayal brought grace and authenticity to the character and helped solidify Coming to America as a classic. Still, fans can’t help but wonder what might have been.

Had Lisa Lisa accepted the role, it’s possible her trajectory in entertainment would have expanded beyond music into mainstream acting. The combination of her star appeal and Murphy’s comedic genius could have added a new dynamic to the film, offering a different kind of chemistry and spotlight.

While Shari Headley’s performance remains beloved, this bit of Hollywood history adds an intriguing layer to the film’s legacy. It’s a reminder of how off-screen decisions—personal or professional—can shape the stories that become cultural landmarks.

Today, both Lisa Lisa and Coming to America are celebrated icons of their era. One ruled the music charts, the other helped define a generation of comedy. And though their paths didn’t cross on the big screen, the story behind the casting remains a fascinating footnote in the making of a classic film.

Sometimes, what almost happened is just as interesting as what did.